Lapidaryforum.net
Let's Rock => Identifications of Materials => Topic started by: MGoy on November 17, 2016, 10:55:12 AM
-
Hello, I found a rock in Lyme Regis a while a go, Ive had a bash at identifying it.
I personally think its Obsidian, but finding it in Lyme Regis would be (in my understanding) unusual.
I went to a friend too, He suggested "because it's in Lyme Regis it'd be likely to be sedimentary, it's quite dark indicating organic matter once in it. Reminds me a bit of shale but usually shale has good cleavage".
Its kinda stumped us both, so I decided to look for a forum which covers this kind of subject.
I'm hoping you can help me and im not being invasive in requesting so.
So here it is ...
[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
My calculations of volume (very rough) , weight of rock : 35.5 grams , volume : 12.369 cm^3, Density : 2.87 grams per cubic centimeter.
[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
Thanks in advance for any help given, all questions or observations gladly received.
-
Did you check the hardness? It could be flint or a fine grained basalt. Jasper and agate can flake like that too
-
I had to look up Lyme Regis to see where it was at. If the rock
Is a 7 hardness I will bet on flint. It has the right color. If there are no flint quarries near there it may have been carried in by Palio people.
-
I'm also thinking it's probably flint or chert. There are several cliff areas near Lyme Regis where both seem abundant according to this pdf:
http://jncc.defra.gov.uk/pdf/gcrdb/GCRsiteaccount2109.pdf
-
Thank you for the feedback.
I had no idea flint could be so shiny, although its flatness becomes less unusual..
Hardness... I'm not sure how to check that.
I have attempted to scratch it with steel, stone and quarts.
I think the quarts manage to scratch it, but only minutely, while the quarts took a significant chip to itself.
I thought i had seen flint before, how interesting that my expectations would be so different.
Thank you :)
-
Quartz is a 7 hardness. If it won't scratch with Quartz it is at least 7. Flint and chert are 7. It looks like a couple of flakes were chipped off by Palio people maybe checking the quality to see if it would be good for making a tool out of. You may have a cavemans reject
-
Wow, that's awesome. Just to think that this rock could have been in the hands of someone else thousands of years ago.
Ok then, if you could indulge my interest a little further what are the straight line markings? I assumed before that its a cutting mark, but presumably in order to cut you need a saw, which implies metal, which implies that if this is in fact a piece of rejected flint for tools, that doesn't make sense. Unless it was cut to make gun flint. Or those aren't cut marks at all, which would interest me in knowing what it actually was.
Here is a closer look.
EDIT : Why is my picture so massive? please let me know how to reduce its size.
[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
-
Tough to tell from the photos, but have you ruled out glass? Surface could be tumbled/worn. Fractures look glassy. Some glass is opaque. Hardness seems right for glass.
-Jeremy
-
Hello MGoy and welcome to the forum!
You need to use a resizer to shrink your photos before you upload them. I use FastStone Photo Resizer which you can find here (it's free): http://www.faststone.org/download.htm
I usually make them 600 x 800 to use on the forum.
-
I'm going with glass. The thickness is too regular and those lines don't look like something nature would come up with.
-
Im no expert but would my density calculations put it outside the realms of glass. Is there any test I can do?
Thanks administrator, I'll be straight on the. And thanks for the welcome, you guys are very helpful :)
-
im saying its just glass, that face of the piece is too rippled like a potato chip to be natural.
-
Oh bum :(
To be fooled by a piece of glass, what a waste of time.
My apologies to you, people of this forum. I have sullied your forum with pictures of glass! By the looks.
-
Slice it into strips the long way, drill holes in one end, hang from a piece of driftwood, and you have some nice wind chimes.
-
Glass is actually very fun to work with. Shape it
-
Glass is easily scratched with Quartz. You didn't have any success when you tried to scratch! So I vote not glass.
-
My kids and i actually walk the beaches for glass
-
I had a Knee Jerk reaction of disappointment when I thought it could be man made glass. But then after letting that idea settle, I became more doubtful, I as a human being have a ton of experience with man made glass and this...... thing, does not feel like it, I know it is worn beyond any recognition.
My arguments against :
* Its 6mm thick, uncommon for man made glass?
* Its so very very very dark black (I have suspicions it may actually be very very very dark purple in reality), there is 0% light getting through it, again uncommon?
* My density calculation (If correct) of 2.87 puts it outside the range of normal man made glass (2.5 - 2.8 I believe)
* I believe it to be harder than man made glass
My arguments against :
* Those marking are 99% certainty man made
* This is me im talking about, the chances of me going to a famous geological site and picking up a man made object for the sake of irony..
* There was works rubble on site, increasing the odds.
I'm sure you and your family make great things from found glass, and you have a great time doing so, I'm sorry about my knee jerk judgement about man made glass.
There's something about this thing, when i hold it I'm so so certain its not just a bit of glass or a bit of bathroom tile etc, I could of course be wrong. It would be nice to know for sure.
Thank you :)
-
Calculating density by dimension is virtually impossible. Try displacement instead. Fill a container with water and weigh it. Then put your sample in and remove. This is easier if you tie a piece of fishing line around it first. Then weigh again to find the weight of water that has been displaced. This will give an accurate volume to check against the weight of the sample. Be sure to wipe the outside dry before weighing.
Those lines certainly appear to be made by machine but I can't think of any machine that would do that other than a metal planer. That's not something that would be used on any natural material or even glass.
-
I believe the lines would have been molded in when the piece was produced. Agree that displacement method is better used to try and determine density. Does it scratch glass?
-Jeremy
-
Not all glass is thin, or transparent. That could be some kind of structural glass. I think they used a lot of that in the 1950's. Or it could have served some industrial purpose, an insulator of some kind. The evenness of the thickness, and those grooves, are certainly human made. It could even be a piece of slag glass.
-
Right I have done what has been suggested :
As follows, I first got a glass of water and used a pippette to get the water level above the rim of the glass.
[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
I then lowered the ... thing, via a thread into the water, being careful to be slow and not touch the bottom of the glass.
[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
After removing the thing . . . and drying up all spillages i weighed the water filled glass again.
[ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
Glass Full : 683 grams
Glass After : 670 grams
Difference : 13 grams, weight of water 1gram per 1cm^3
Therefore this thing is 13cm^3
36grams / 13cm^3 = 2.769grams per cubic centimeter.
It looks like it is in fact in the realms of glass, although right on the edge in density.