Lapidaryforum.net

Let's Rock => Identifications of Materials => Topic started by: olgguy on November 22, 2016, 02:17:05 PM

Title: Thunder Egg from where?
Post by: olgguy on November 22, 2016, 02:17:05 PM
Found in the last Estate sale collection I bought. Wondering where from.
Title: Re: Thunder Egg from where?
Post by: panaMark on November 22, 2016, 10:03:51 PM
Actually I don't think it is a thunderegg, but instead a roundish agate nodule. A nice one too. Most thundereggs have a basalt round encapsulation.

As I understand it, the agate penetrates the basalt and over time replaces it or fills a void. Then I am thinking maybe the chalcedony "grows' a bit out from the center and strengthens the basalt in a round manner so that when the basalt mass eventually weathers to dirt, the strengthened egg remains.  Maybe an expert can clarify or correct if I am wrong.
Title: Re: Thunder Egg from where?
Post by: rocks2dust on November 22, 2016, 11:36:43 PM
Thundereggs have a rhyolite shell that weathers out of the basalt, but I agree it's not a t-egg. Rather, it looks like amygdular agate (agate that forms within a vesicle within basalt, then weathers or is knocked out). Very pretty colors in that, but perhaps difficult to pin down a location. Similar blues in amygdular agates come from several areas around the Northwest, but I cannot recall seeing one with a streak of cerise like that.
Title: Re: Thunder Egg from where?
Post by: Jhon P on November 23, 2016, 12:46:29 PM
It looks like the agate nodules we collect at Fairview mt the in Nevada
Title: Re: Thunder Egg from where?
Post by: olgguy on November 23, 2016, 12:57:13 PM
OK, so far we have agate nodules, Thundereggs with Rhyolite shells. Now I have found, I think Rhyolite with the inside filled with Mud, as a Geode, Quartz, and Agate. Are all these Rhyolite and called the same name?
Title: Re: Thunder Egg from where?
Post by: 55fossil on November 23, 2016, 04:34:36 PM
As for your pictures the first one looks like a thunder egg that is not well filled with agate. The second one looks like a Mexican coconut. The second one is considered a geode because it is hollow. Geodes can have just about anything or nothing in them. Yours is very nice and may actually be a different variety as I am not an expert. I have no idea what to accurately call the other two "eggs".

What is a Thunder Egg? As a general term they are a rhyolite shell filled with agate (or a geode) that formed in the gas pocket in volcanic flows. I have found them in hard basalt, volcanic ash and other volcanic materials. When you get lucky you find them in decomposed rhyolite and just dig em out quick and easy.Some thunder eggs lose there rhyolite shell and all you find is a agate core that may be many different shapes. Just look at all the shapes of the inside of thunder eggs for sale.
Title: Re: Thunder Egg from where?
Post by: rocks2dust on November 23, 2016, 06:46:19 PM
55fossil is right. The one on the left is a collapsed t-egg with not much agate filling. Can't tell much from the exterior of the egg as to origin. The other 3 are all Mexican Las Choyas Coconuts. The hollow ones are kept as specimens and sell for more than the solid ones, which can be good for slabbing.
Title: Re: Thunder Egg from where?
Post by: olgguy on November 23, 2016, 07:32:22 PM
         well I want to thank you all. The reason I wanted the info is because I have a lot of sorting to do.