Lapidaryforum.net

Let's Rock => Identifications of Materials => Topic started by: OurEarthlyDesigns on May 16, 2017, 03:33:26 PM

Title: Please help with identification
Post by: OurEarthlyDesigns on May 16, 2017, 03:33:26 PM
I bought this rock, and the seller couldn't tell me much about it. I believe he said something about manganese. Currently I'm not able to do any tests or anything on it, but I do think it is agate. Any insight would be appreciated. If you know what it is, and you know locations where this might be from - even better.
Thanks,
Michael
Our Earthly Designs
Title: Re: Please help with identification
Post by: rocks2dust on May 16, 2017, 03:43:10 PM
It is a dendritic agate. The dendrites could be manganese, which is probably what you are recalling. It looks similar to some Oregon agate, but I'm not recalling a locale off the top of my head.
Title: Re: Please help with identification
Post by: irockhound on May 16, 2017, 10:43:25 PM
Not to confuse Dendritic Agate and Plume Agate.  That technically would be a plume agate as you had stated correctly in your other posting the 3 dimensional nature of the inclusion.  Some of these types of plumes occasionally exhibit small crystal growths in the plumes that look like a pyrite or specular hematite.  They will show often a change in color in the plumes depending on how the light bounces off the plume giving a pale green or sometimes red halo.
Title: Re: Please help with identification
Post by: Slabbercabber on May 17, 2017, 07:07:54 AM
All of the manganese I've seen is black.  Is brown a possible color for it?
Title: Re: Please help with identification
Post by: Gergis on May 17, 2017, 07:19:39 AM
I think thats psilomelane agate from texas. I've cut a couple in the past and currently have a piece on the work bench.

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Please help with identification
Post by: rocks2dust on May 17, 2017, 11:04:03 AM
Yes, manganese can be brown. It starts out as a bright silvery gray but can oxidize to pink-red, brown and ultimately black. Add a bit of sulfur or other common minerals and you can get a rainbow of additional colors.

I'm aware that some respected writers have opined that dendrites must be flattened tree/shrub cross sections, but dendrites can, and frequently do, also form stand-alone 3D shapes. These 3D metallic crystallization formations are properly not "plumes" but dendrites. These crystalized formations are found around smelters and foundries as well as in nature both freestanding and encapsulated within rocks. In more translucent agates, the 3D formations do more resemble plumes (feathers) rather than dendrites (branching trees/shrubs). Some dendrites do grow along veils, cracks and other weak points, producing flat, tree/shrub cross-sections. The weak areas that allow the new minerals to penetrate need not always be flat. In other cases, full, stand-alone 3D dendrites are later encapsulated in opaque agate, jasper or what have you, and the tree/shrub cross-section pattern is only revealed when cut (which is why we have dendritic jaspers, even when the formation continues through several cuts, and don't call those plume jaspers). Metallic dendrites are sometimes etched out of host rocks to reveal their 3D shapes by collectors.

Whether they are called "plume" or "dendrite" in agate probably depends more on the translucency and whatever the person naming the rock first saw. For example, the copper formations in artificial Fischer Stone agates are usually termed dendrites, even though the material is translucent and they more resemble plume agate formations. Fischer and those following knew he was producing metallic dendrites, but if encountered in nature, I suspect it would have been christened a "plume" agate.
Title: Re: Please help with identification
Post by: OurEarthlyDesigns on May 17, 2017, 10:18:52 PM
Thanks for all the help and suggestions. A lot of great information which is why I love this forum so much - a lot of knowledgeable people. I really admire that, and that all of you are so helpful. I was looking online, and was thinking that it resembled medicine bow agate displayed here https://rubymountain5rocks.com/product-category/slabs-a-b/black-plume-agate/ . What do you guys think?
Title: Re: Please help with identification
Post by: mirkaba on May 18, 2017, 10:35:44 AM
More likely than not it is Medicine Bow Dendritic Agate. I just cut a bunch of it.
Title: Re: Please help with identification
Post by: OurEarthlyDesigns on May 18, 2017, 10:47:43 AM
More likely than not it is Medicine Bow Dendritic Agate. I just cut a bunch of it.
Awesome! Do you have any finished pictures. I'd love to see it.
Title: Re: Please help with identification
Post by: rocks2dust on May 18, 2017, 04:18:17 PM
Others may have more photos, but here is an old pic of Medicine Bow:
(http://i777.photobucket.com/albums/yy56/gemphoto12/quartzes/_agate_medicinebow03.jpg)
There is a lot of Parral agate around these days (Mexico) that can look similar to Medicine Bow, as well as quite a few others with near-black to brown dendrites or plumes. Although these old pics may not looks as close to yours as Medicine Bow, I've seen other pieces of these with that do look close - these are just the photos I happen to still have on photobucket:
(http://i777.photobucket.com/albums/yy56/gemphoto12/quartzes/_agate_arco_id02.jpg) (http://i777.photobucket.com/albums/yy56/gemphoto12/quartzes/_agate_amethystsaage_nv02.jpg) (http://i777.photobucket.com/albums/yy56/gemphoto12/quartzes/_agate_snakeriver_id02.jpg)
(left to right) Arco (tubes and dendrites, Idaho), Amethyst Sage (Nevada), Snake River (Idaho)
I still haven't recalled the name of the piece I remember with dark brown dendrites. I want to think it was from Jackson County in SW Oregon. There are many others than just these, however. The Medicine Bow can have pits, but generally doesn't undercut so much as some others (polishes up real in the more solid pieces).